As the appetite for Chinese students joining summer camps in the United Kingdom rebounds in the post-pandemic era, educators and program organizers are taking a more reflective look at what truly makes these short-term overseas experiences meaningful.

Dong Qing, a secondary school teacher in the UK who has spent several years organizing summer programs for visiting Chinese students, offers valuable insights into the rewards — and the missed opportunities — that these programs often present.

"I have witnessed both the growth and challenges the Chinese students experience in a foreign environment," she said.

"While summer schools are highly popular, the actual benefits vary greatly among participants. The key difference lies in whether students are willing to step out of their comfort zones and fully embrace this invaluable international opportunity."

While some students made remarkable progress, Dong observed that many tended to stay within familiar social circles, mainly interacting with peers from China. Although this provided emotional comfort, it often limited their ability to engage more broadly.

"The true value of a summer school lies in engaging with diverse cultures," she said. "Those who actively interacted with students from other countries, participated in discussions and embraced activities showed real progress — not just in language, but in confidence and cross-cultural understanding."

There were others who remained reserved or distracted, particularly because of their smartphones. "Excessive phone use was a significant concern," Dong said.

"Whether in dining halls, dormitories or even classrooms, many are absorbed in their digital worlds, neglecting real-life interactions. This habit hinders language improvement and diminishes the overall quality of their summer school experience."

To counter this, Dong recommended that parents and schools work together to manage screen time more effectively. Measures such as setting "phone-free hours" and encouraging journaling or collaborative group projects could help students stay present and engaged.

Equally important, she emphasized, is the need to better integrate classroom learning with real-world exploration. "The essence of a study tour should not be a rigid combination of classes, activities and sightseeing, but rather a seamless integration of all three," she said. "For instance, visiting London after a history and geography lesson on the city reinforces classroom knowledge, while doing some treasure hunt activities in museums and galleries encourages them to learn proactively."

In her view, the most effective summer programs followed a "learn-experience-reflect" model that allowed students to internalize what they encountered and apply it meaningfully.

"Though summer schools are short-term, their impact can be long-lasting," Dong said. "But only by encouraging communication, managing smartphone use wisely and connecting lessons with reallife experiences can students transform this opportunity into lifelong personal and academic growth."

As more Chinese families look to the UK for summer learning opportunities, Dong hopes students will not only see the world — but learn to navigate it.

"The world is right in front of them," she said. "The question is whether they are ready to step into it."